As Scholars Use AI To Write Papers, They Raise Many New Questions
In “What even is an author?,” Katherine Mangan and Shea Vance grapple with a troubling question that the increasing use of AI in scholarly writing is raising at universities: At what point does authorship even matter now in academia? Simon Goldstein A recent article in Philosophy & Public Affairs by University of Hong Kong philosophy prof Simon Goldstein illustrates the conundrum: Goldstein disclosed his use of AI in the article’s “acknowledgements” section and in a separate five-page report detailing how Claude contributed each step of the way. “The paper was an experiment in writing with AI,” he wrote “ — in how far Claude could go as, in effect, the Ph.D. student, with the author acting as something like a very generous Ph.D. supervisor.” After Goldstein told Claude the “basic idea,” it “wrote almost all of the prose in the paper,” he wrote. Goldstein told The Chronicle that he would have listed Claude as the first author and himself as the second had the journal allowed that. He did almost none of the actual writing, …





.png?trim=0%2C0%2C0%2C0&width=1200&height=800&crop=1200%3A800&ssl=1)
