How ‘Love Story’ Star Paul Anthony Kelly Became JFK Jr.
How hot is too hot? A few days before Ryan Murphy’s eagerly anticipated series Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette hits streaming, I find myself in a dimly-lit Chinese tea parlor with Paul Anthony Kelly, the 37-year-old model-turned-actor lately plucked from relative obscurity to play the show’s titular John-John, looking through a menu of Cantonese dishes and trying to gauge how much heat this Canadian-born white boy can take. “Honestly, the spicier the better,” he tells me with a grin. “I eat everything.” We’re meeting at a very strange time in his life. A year ago, Kelly was just another male model in his late 30s. Modeling had always been good to him, keeping him gainfully employed for almost two decades, but he had also, maybe, maxed out in that world. He’d walked the runways for Vivenne Westwood, worked in Tokyo and Hong Kong (where he built up a tolerance for chili oil), and modeled in catalogs for everyone from Eddie Bauer to Brooks Brothers, but it was clear he wasn’t going …







