Are you being emotionally manipulated? Why an Oscar contender is splitting opinion about emotional response
If you’ve been following the ongoing awards race, you can’t have escaped the fact that Jessie Buckley has been lavished with acclaim for her leading turn in Chloë Zhao’s film Hamnet. The drama – adapted from Maggie O’Farrell’s 2020 historical fiction novel of the same name – sees the Irish actress take on the role of Agnes, the wife of William Shakespeare who experiences unimaginable tragedy when her titular son dies from the bubonic plague. After debuting at least year’s Telluride Film Festival, early word on the film, and especially its devastating emotional impact, was ecstatic. Our own 5-star Radio Times review, was full of praise – with critic James Mottram calling it a “masterly study of loss”. He added: “The finale, all set around a stage performance, lives long in the memory, making this quietly-hewn movie feel utterly wrenching.” That verdict was by no means an anomaly. The film was met with a wave of extremely positive reviews, many of which emphasised the sheer visceral nature of the grief depicted by Buckley’s performance as …




