All posts tagged: martina valković

Conversation and Context in an Online World

Conversation and Context in an Online World

Communicating online can be thrilling. We can interact instantly with people anywhere in the world. We can find and consult with experts on any conceivable topic. And we can find kindred spirits and comrades with whom to build valuable communities not possible in offline life. And yet, it can also be maddening. We may struggle to express our true feelings with text alone (however many emoji we throw in). We may find ourselves attacked by hateful speakers emboldened by the cover of anonymity. We may, on occasion, undergo the profoundly lonely, soul-destroying realization that we are talking to a bot and not a person. And, more commonly than all of these, we can find ourselves mired in misunderstandings and miscommunications, unclear of whom we’re talking to, what we’re talking about, and who is listening. Experiences of the latter kind bring into relief some of the starkest differences between online and offline communication. They also make clear the limitations of traditional philosophical models of conversation. Historically, such models have assumed the following about a standard conversation. …

Should Vegan Advocacy Meet People Where They Are?

Should Vegan Advocacy Meet People Where They Are?

When we aim to justify veganism, a crucial question is how to frame the arguments. A widespread and intuitively compelling strategy is to adjust the message so that it fits with the preexisting values of the interlocutor: Suppose you are speaking with someone who cares deeply about climate change. In that case, it seems reasonable to address the environmental costs of animal agriculture, such as greenhouse gas emissions, land use, or deforestation. Or take an interlocutor who is particularly concerned with their personal health. Here, one might focus on how diets high in animal products are linked to health problems such as cardiovascular disease, high blood pressure, or type 2 diabetes. So, it seems plausible that vegan advocacy should pay attention to what people already value or hope for. I call this approach tailored advocacy, meaning that vegan advocacy focuses on climate arguments for climate-conscious audiences, health arguments for health-conscious audiences, arguments about the impact of animal agriculture on world hunger for people concerned with global poverty, and so on. To start, it is important …

Free to Speak, Not to Listen: Freedom of Expression in the Age of AI Chatbots

Free to Speak, Not to Listen: Freedom of Expression in the Age of AI Chatbots

Can you lose your free speech even when you are not prevented from saying anything? To answer this question, let us consider two ways in which governments could regulate AI chatbots in the near future. First, imagine a government prohibiting the commercialization of AI chatbots that fail to meet safety benchmarks. For instance, chatbots should not provide users with detailed instructions for building weapons, generate dangerous conspiracy theories, or encourage self-harm. We’ll call this case AI Safety. My second case is Political Bias. In this scenario, the government prohibits the commercialization of AI chatbots unless their developer can demonstrate that the chatbots are not politically biased and that the information they provide on controversial issues reflects a diversity of viewpoints. Would any of these scenarios violate stakeholders’ moral right to freedom of expression? This, of course, depends on who the stakeholders are. Consider, for a moment, that AI chatbots might possess speech rights. This may seem preposterous, but some scholars argue that conversational AI agents have a legal right to freedom of expression. Yet there are serious philosophical reasons to …

A Bridge, a Door and the Landscape Closer By

A Bridge, a Door and the Landscape Closer By

Standing atop a skyscraper, gazing out over the sea of buildings below, we may be tempted to call what lays before us an “urban landscape.” After all, we are admiring the stunning effect of the setting sun, the undulation of light it creates on the rooftops below at different heights, similar to the experience we have when standing on a hilltop or on a cliff by the ocean. However, what we are doing is transposing a peculiar type of experience to a context that is alien to its specificity. Landscape is used in an array of fields as an illustration of something it is not, namely, a mere visual—even two-dimensional—setting: a scenery, a view, or worse, a framework. We hear about the political landscape, the emotional landscape, or even a reduction to the suffix -scape (mindscape, tablescape) which, to put it bluntly, has not much to do with the landscape proper. Such designations strip landscape of its substance and density; it becomes an empty shell. Green cities, no matter how environmentally friendly or sustainable, are …

2023 Central Division Presidential Address: The Lincoln Virtues

2023 Central Division Presidential Address: The Lincoln Virtues

Below is the audio recording of Connie Rosati’s presidential address, “The Lincoln Virtues,” given at the 2023 Central Division Meeting. The full text is available on the APA website (member sign-in is required).  The audio of the lecture is available here: “The Lincoln Virtues” by Connie Rosati Connie Rosati is the Roy Allison Vaughan Centennial Professor in Philosophy and Professor of Law at the University of Texas at Austin. She has a Ph.D. in philosophy from the University of Michigan and a J.D. from Harvard Law School. Prior to joining the faculty at UT Austin, she taught at the University of Arizona, Rutgers University, Northwestern University, the University of Michigan, the University of California, Davis, the University of Pennsylvania Law School, and the University of San Diego Law School. Her research interests include metaethics, ethics, philosophy of law, constitutional theory, political philosophy, and action theory. She served as president of the APA Central Division in 2022–2023. About this series: The Blog of the APA is pleased to publish the presidential addresses and John Dewey Lectures …

Kant Among the Penguins: Social Contract Theory for the Anthropocene

Kant Among the Penguins: Social Contract Theory for the Anthropocene

Penguins in Antarctica are adjusting their seasonal breeding practices at record rates for vertebrate animals. Three species of penguins (Adélie, Chinstrap, and Gentoo) have each adapted to fast-rising temperatures by moving up their breeding season by more than a week (nearly two weeks for the Gentoo penguins). Of course, such sudden adaptations are not ideal for those making them: All of the intricate patterns of prey movement, weather, landscape changes, predation threats, and competition that affect the penguin reproductive cycle ideally fit together, having evolved gradually over long periods of time, constantly adjusting to changes as they happen. Moreover, rapid adaptation to a changing climate tends to benefit generalists at the expense of more specialized species (in this case, the fish-eating Gentoo are expanding their range while the krill-specialist Adélie and Chinstrap penguins are facing challenging if variable conditions). The point is not that penguin practices were once fixed and now they have to change. It’s that the rate of adaptation required is much higher than it has been. Changes wrought by human beings are …

Birds of a Feather Flock Together: Nepotism, Networking, and Structural Injustice

Birds of a Feather Flock Together: Nepotism, Networking, and Structural Injustice

“Network, network, network” is the advice given to many job-seekers and for good reason. It is thought, for example, that over 60% of jobs are never advertised and instead exist within what is euphemistically referred to as the “hidden labor market.” Additionally, many sociologists have observed the crucial role that social ties play in the procurement of work, with some estimating that over half of all jobs within the U.S. are acquired through one’s relatives and friends. On reflection, many individuals will recognize that many of their own economic opportunities have stemmed from the social networks that they are placed within, and perhaps just as many of us have been blocked from progression, at one time or another, due to a lack of social connection, informal sponsorship, and the kind of social capital that can be converted into meaningful employment, income, and wealth. One notable and frequently contested mechanism through which the opportunities tethered to one’s social network can be converted is nepotism. As I have argued elsewhere, when individuals engage in nepotism, they are …

Beyond Left and Right? Thinking Along the Lines of a Dividing Question

Beyond Left and Right? Thinking Along the Lines of a Dividing Question

Recently, the Foundation for Philosophical Orientation launched an essay contest asking a provocative question: “Is the left-right distinction still useful for political orientation?” I briefly considered writing a submission—after all, the first prize was $10,000. I had a few things on my mind, and yet I couldn’t find anything incisive about this matter, which tends to antagonize people in the blink of an eye. I forwarded the link to a couple of philosopher friends who I thought were more suited for delivering proper punches in this kind of contest. “Hey, don’t you want to win ten thousand dollars?” I asked half-jokingly. One of them, who now considers himself a former leftist (and is completely into AI theory and business), replied without hesitation: “Oh, I can answer that question without any prize money. Simply: no.” I was amused by this straightforward, blunt answer, yet it didn’t really surprise me. While both sides have their ardent defenders, there are also people who might shrug their shoulders at the debate, maybe because they have lost hope of taming …

Trade Unions and the Shaping of Public Opinion in Mass Democracy

Trade Unions and the Shaping of Public Opinion in Mass Democracy

Democracy’s transformation into mass politics has always gone hand-in-hand with new forms of political communication and media. From the early American republic to fin de siècle Europe, the expansion of suffrage created a mass voting public whose attention became the currency of politics. Unlike ancient Athenian democracy—with its lotteries and assembled citizenry—modern democracy quickly became a rowdy arena of journalists, campaign managers, and hucksters competing, often unscrupulously, for public attention. In our digital mass democracy, that rowdiness has only intensified with the explosion of competing sources of political information and appeals. Moments of mass democracy, including our own, hold out a participatory promise while presenting risks of manipulation. For one, election cycles and expanding media can generate widely available, trustworthy information that makes possible citizens’ informed debate over vital issues of public concern. Public opinion can become a body that thinks and acts—even if only slowly or, at times, reactively. Yet the media-driven election campaign can also present new opportunities for elites to employ disinformation and deception to shape public opinion. To counter these risks, …

Where Measurement Ends, Need Begins

Where Measurement Ends, Need Begins

This post was originally published in Kronika: Filozofski magazin as “Gdje prestaje mjerenje, počinje potreba.” It has been translated by the author and reproduced here with the permission of Kronika. I’m certain you’ve come across the phrases “penny for your thoughts” and “food for thought” at some point in your life. Perhaps you’ve even used them. If so, with the first you politely asked someone what was on their mind. With the second, you signaled the value of an idea (or of some content that prompted you to think more deeply, or think at all) whether you received it or, better yet, produced it yourself, perhaps giving others a reason to do the same. I love those phrases. They serve well as a frame for something that preoccupies many people in academia, perhaps without their even realizing it; and that is the phenomenon of obsolescence. Not the legal kind—the statute of limitations, the expired claim, the debt that can no longer be collected—but the kind that describes a particular human wear-and-tear within a system. The academic system, specifically. I …