The Country You’re Angry at Is Partly Imagined
Two people describe the same politician. One writes, “A disgusting monster destroying America.” The other writes, “I disagree with his policies.” Give them a policy survey and their answers look almost identical: taxes, immigration, health care, all broadly similar. What differs is not the belief, but the volume. Much of what looks like division is volume. And even within a single party, people agree far less than they think. The referee stops calling fouls Picture a referee at a game between two rival teams. As long as he stays neutral, both sides play straighter, because nobody wants to foul in front of a fair judge. Now let the referee pick a side. He does not stop blowing the whistle. He stops blowing it for the same fouls. This is consistent with what we found with 2,400 Americans. Some people divided $10 between two strangers, one who loved Trump and one who opposed him, while keeping none of it for themselves. A bystander could then judge their behavior and dock their bonus for the split. When …








