The Problem With Learning Logical Fallacies
Logical fallacies are mistakes in arguments. For example, if someone says that something is better solely because it is more “natural,” this is the appeal to nature fallacy. If someone presents two options as mutually exclusive when they are not, this is a false dilemma. If someone misrepresents someone else’s argument to make it easier to rebut, it’s called a straw man fallacy. Learning to recognize logical fallacies can be useful because it can protect us from manipulation and help us keep conversations on track. But gaining only a superficial knowledge of logical fallacies can backfire, and it may undermine our ability to communicate clearly and evaluate claims. Risk 1: Over-Identifying Fallacies When we first learn about logical fallacies, we might start seeing them everywhere. This is not surprising since fallacies can be found all over the place! However, not everything that sounds like a fallacy is a fallacy. This inclination to look for fallacies can be problematic if we start identifying every “fallacy-shaped” statement as a fallacy. Most logical fallacies are informal fallacies. This …



