All posts tagged: Logical

The Problem With Learning Logical Fallacies

The Problem With Learning Logical Fallacies

Logical fallacies are mistakes in arguments. For example, if someone says that something is better solely because it is more “natural,” this is the appeal to nature fallacy. If someone presents two options as mutually exclusive when they are not, this is a false dilemma. If someone misrepresents someone else’s argument to make it easier to rebut, it’s called a straw man fallacy. Learning to recognize logical fallacies can be useful because it can protect us from manipulation and help us keep conversations on track. But gaining only a superficial knowledge of logical fallacies can backfire, and it may undermine our ability to communicate clearly and evaluate claims. Risk 1: Over-Identifying Fallacies When we first learn about logical fallacies, we might start seeing them everywhere. This is not surprising since fallacies can be found all over the place! However, not everything that sounds like a fallacy is a fallacy. This inclination to look for fallacies can be problematic if we start identifying every “fallacy-shaped” statement as a fallacy. Most logical fallacies are informal fallacies. This …

New research challenges the idea that logical thinking diminishes religious belief

New research challenges the idea that logical thinking diminishes religious belief

Activating analytical thinking does not appear to reduce a person’s religious beliefs. This finding provides evidence against the popular idea that leaning on logic directly diminishes faith. The findings were recently published in the journal Psychology of Religion and Spirituality. Luz Acera Martini, a doctoral fellow and doctoral candidate in psychology at the National Scientific and Technical Research Council, and Esteban Freidin, a researcher at the National Scientific and Technical Research Council with a doctorate in philosophy, conducted the research. Both scientists are affiliated with the Universidad Nacional del Sur in Argentina. They sought to examine exactly how cognitive styles influence faith. Previous studies in the cognitive science of religion suggested that engaging in analytical thinking could suppress the basic mental intuitions that make religious beliefs appealing. Many psychologists think that human reasoning relies on two main systems. One system is fast and intuitive, while the other is slow and analytical. Some past experiments indicated that exposing people to tasks that prompt slow, logical thought could lower their reported religious beliefs. This concept assumes that …

How cognitive ability and logical intuition evolve during middle and high school

How cognitive ability and logical intuition evolve during middle and high school

Higher cognitive ability in adults typically predicts accurate gut instincts, but this mental shortcut takes time to develop. A new study involving middle and high school students reveals that young people rely heavily on slower, deliberate thinking to solve logical puzzles before their correct intuitions fully mature. The research was recently published in the journal Thinking & Reasoning. Psychologists often divide human thought into two distinct categories based on speed and effort. The first type of thinking is fast, automatic, and requires very little mental energy. The second type is slow, deliberate, and demands sustained attention to detail. For decades, researchers assumed that successfully solving a math or logic puzzle always required the second, slower type of thought. In this traditional view, our fast assumptions are often biased or flawed. To reach a mathematically sound conclusion, a person has to actively block their immediate instincts and spend time calculating the right answer. Recent studies on adult reasoning have challenged this assumption. Scientists have found that many adults can produce correct, logical answers almost instantly. They …

Micro Softy 74: The Cretan Paradox & Logical Illusions

Micro Softy 74: The Cretan Paradox & Logical Illusions

There are optical illusions and auditory illusions. This week’s Micro Softy concerns logical illusions.  Two optical illusions are shown in Figure 1.    On the left, the “Mad poiuyt” appeared on the cover of MAD Magazine in March 1965.   On the right, stairs repeat themselves in an impossible illusion. If you walk clockwise, you are always going downstairs forever. This staircase was used in the surreal art of M.C. Escher.  Figure 1: Two optical illusions. / WikipediaLeft, WikipediaRight.  The Shepard-Risset glissando is an auditory illusion where the pitch of a sound appears to continuously rise or fall indefinitely. Christopher Nolan’s films like Dunkirk and The Dark Knight used it to heighten the sense of dread or relentless motion. It can be used to create the illusion of an endless climb or descent, or to signify a special event, as in Super Mario 64’s endless staircase.  A tone that decreased in pitch forever is not possible. The Shepard-Risset glissando is an auditory illusion.    Logical Illusions  This week’s Micro Softy is about logical illusions. Here’s a classic example.  Epimenides, a 6th-century BC philosopher from Crete, reportedly said:  “All Cretans are liars.”  The Apostle Paul repeated this claim in the New Testament book of Titus.  “One of Crete’s own prophets has said it: `Cretans are always liars …’ ”  [Titus 1:12]   The logic illusion paradox arises when we consider that Epimenides himself is a Cretan. Suppose …

The Logical End Point of ‘America First’ Foreign Aid

The Logical End Point of ‘America First’ Foreign Aid

Last summer, the Dalai Lama was having a party in Dharamshala for his 90th birthday, and Bethany Morrison, a newly appointed State Department official, was eager to meet with him there. Inconveniently, the United States had recently canceled about $12 million worth of annual foreign aid benefiting Tibetan-exile communities as part of the implosion of USAID. This, Morrison and other State officials thought, would not make a particularly good impression on His Holiness, according to a former State and a former USAID official. Prior to the Dalai Lama’s birthday, the two former federal employees told me, they had spent months lobbying for Donald Trump’s administration to restore at least some Asia-based aid projects. They had argued that these projects passed Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s new litmus test for overseas spending: They would make America “safer, stronger, and more prosperous.” Nothing changed. (Like other aid workers I spoke with for this story, the former employees requested anonymity because of fear of professional reprisal.) But as the party’s date approached, Jeremy Lewin, the new head of …