Sarah Pidgeon on Carolyn Bessette Kennedy Style, Criticism
To play ’90s power couple John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette, Ryan Murphy and the team behind FX’s Love Story took the Star Is Born route: they cast two unknowns. For JFK Jr.’s role, creator Connor Hines saw more than 1,000 actors before landing on Paul Anthony Kelly. Sarah Pidgeon, meanwhile, emerged as an immediate frontrunner to play Carolyn from her first audition tape. In recent years, she’s appeared in Tiny Beautiful Things, earned a 2024 Tony nomination for Stereophonic and had a major role in last summer’s I Know What You Did Last Summer legacy sequel. Now, she’s entering a new realm of fame. Much like the real Carolyn — a rising star at Calvin Klein who worked her way up to become a publicist — Pidgeon’s career is beginning to mirror that elusive “It” girl trajectory, earning rave reviews for her performance. Still, the actress felt the weight of portraying a figure so beloved for her signature minimalist style. Carolyn Bessette’s aura and famed wardrobe remain touchstones of fashion inspiration, even three …



