Depression as a Philosophical Problem: Rethinking the Meaning of Suffering in the Era of SSRIs
https://www.pexels.com/photo/person-with-bunch-medication-pills-on-hand-3683101/ When I was sixteen, I was hospitalized for depression for six weeks and put on Prozac. At the time, I was taught that depression is, first and foremost, a medical problem. It was a sign that my brain was broken, and that I needed doctors to fix me through a combination of drugs and therapy. I’ve taken antidepressant drugs on and off throughout my adult life. But over the last decade, I’ve come to think of depression as, primarily, a philosophical problem. Depression and its treatment engage some of the deepest questions philosophers ask, such as questions about agency, selfhood, and the good life. To appreciate the philosophical dimension of depression, it’s helpful to take a step back and consider two contrasting paradigms of depression. This helps us see how each one involves distinct, implicit answers to those questions. Two Paradigms of Depression The first picture is the chemical imbalance view—or more generally, the brain dysfunction view. It holds that depression is a brain disease, kind of like epilepsy or Parkinson’s disease. The idea …









