The internet is chock full of talking birds, whether theyâre squawking at a vet, singing âYou are my sunshine,â or annoying cats while barking like a dog (naturally). But why are some birds so chatty? The answer, which we explore on a new episode of the Ask Us Anything podcast, has more to do with love than you might think.Â
Ask Us Anything by Popular Science answers your most outlandish, mind-bending questionsâfrom the everyday things youâve always wondered to the bizarre things you never thought to ask, from âWere there any venomous dinosaursâ to âWhy cavemen and women had straight teeth.â If you have a question for us, send us a note. Nothing is too silly or simple.
This episode is based on the Popular Science article âFrom chirps to âhellosâ: Why some birds talk like people.â
Subscribe to Ask Us Anything
Listen and follow Ask Us Anything on your favorite podcast platform:
Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube | Or wherever you get your podcasts.
Full Episode Transcript
Sarah Durn: Today, we are so lucky to have some very chatty podcast guests. Cosmo?Â
Bird: Was that good?Â
SD: That was so good. Care to elaborate? Anyone else?
Bird: You so cute.
SD: Aw, thank you. Youâre cute too. Now, do you guys wanna introduce yourselves properly?
Bird: Iâm a banana.
SD: Bananas? Yeah. I donât think thatâs right somehow, and you guys arenât coming in super clear either.
Maybe you should check your tiny little bird mics? Okay, well letâs cue that theme music anyway.
Bird: Happy birthday to you. Happy birthdayâŠ
SD: Again, not quite right. Welcome to Ask Us Anything from the editors of Popular Science, where we answer your questions about our weird world.Â
From âWhy canât we remember being babiesâ to âWhy do cats hate water,â no question is too wacky or too simple.
Iâm Sarah Durn, an editor at PopSci.
Annie Colbert: And hello, humans and birds. Iâm Annie Colbert, editor-in-chief.
SD: Welcome, Annie. Here at Popular Science, we canât stop thinking about all the worldâs strangest questions.
AC: And this week weâre wondering why some birds can be so chatty. So Sarah, please explain: Whatâs happening with all these talking birds?
SD: Yeah, well the answerâs actually really sweet. Birds mimic what you say and even how you say it because they love you.
AC: Hmm. Really?
SD: You sound so skeptical. Really. Birds like parrots talk because theyâre trying to connect. Itâs not them doing a weird party trick for attention. Itâs more like theyâre saying, âHey Annie, youâre part of my flock.â
AC: Ugh, sounds so lovely to have bird friends.
SD: It is, but the way they actually pull this offâtheir brains, the anatomy, the whole setupâis even wilder.
AC: Alright, Iâm in, despite my very hot and cold relationship with birds, which we will get into later, I promise. But before we dig into all the bird facts, we want to know: What questions are pecking at your brain?
If thereâs something youâve always wanted to know, submit your question by clicking the âAsk Usâ link at popsci.com/ask. Again thatâs popsci.com/ask, and peck at the âAsk Usâ link.
SD: And weâll be right back after this quick break to chirp through all the birdie details.
Welcome back. Okay. Before we get into the science, Annie, you need to tell us: What is up with you and birds?
AC: Yes. As I hinted at earlier, I have a very complicated relationship with birds that started when I was about five or six and we ended up being the home of this very chatty parrot named Polly that my granny had acquired somehow. Iâm unclear of how my granny even ended up with a parrot, but the parrot ended up living at our house and Polly and I were sworn enemies.
SD: Oh no.
AC: Because every time I wanted to sit down and watch cartoons, she would start yelling and squawking, so I couldnât hear the TV. And weâd end up in this shouting match of us yelling, âNo! Shut up!â at each other just at full volume. Like it really soured my relationship with parrots, especially.
SD: Yeah, itâs coming through.
AC: As you can imagine, this did not thrill my parents having a screaming child and a screaming parrot, so they found a new home for Polly. She went to go live with an experienced parrot owner who I would like to point out confirmed that Polly was the loudest parrot she had ever met.
SD: Wow. I mean, how loud is loudest?
AC: Yes. I mean, parrots are loud, but she would scream. You know, we lived in a house and my sister would be walking home from school and could hear us from down the street.Â
SD: Oh my gosh.
AC: Screaming âNo! Shut up!â at each other. It wasnât good. It wasnât good.
SD: Yeah. Youâve been holding onto that for a while.
AC: Yes. Yeah, that was very nice to get off my chest and share. She was very smart, but we were not a good match. How about you? Do you have any parrot encounters?
SD: Not a ton of parrot encounters, but I did have a really, really fun encounter with a raven at the Cleveland Natural History Museum.
AC: Ooh, do tell.
SD: Yeah. They have this outdoor wildlife center. Itâs actually really, really nice where they rehabilitate wounded animals and they had this massive raven sitting on a perch. And I noticed on the little info panel, his name was Blackjack. And to be polite, I said, âHi Blackjack.â
AC: Oh, very friendly.
SD: Yeah. And then Blackjack answered me saying âBlackjack!â
AC: Whoa.
SD: I know. I was with my mom and we both kind of jumped a little and we had this whole little back and forth with him. It was actually really sweet and you know, kind of moving. I mean, itâs like so magical to be able to say words to another animal and for them to say something back that you understand.
I would love to, you know, do that with my dogs or cats, but birds, you know, they can actually do that.
AC: Oh, totally. Itâs a very Disney movie. And it also leads to our big question today, which is why do some birds talk?
SD: Well, first off, we have to define what we mean by talking, because technically almost all birds talk.
AC: Wait, what?
SD: Yeah. Most birds have their own language. They use calls and sounds to say things like, âThereâs a predator nearby,â or, âHey, letâs pair up.â
AC: So birds are constantly talking, just not in a way that we can understand.
SD: Exactly. But when we say talking birds, what we really mean is birds that can mimic human speech.
AC: Mm. Little overachievers.
SD: Totally. And that ability mimicking sounds, including human words, is actually pretty rare. You mostly see it in parrots, but also in birds like crows, ravens, starlings, and mynahs.
AC: So why them? Why do some birds pick this up, but others donât?
SD: A huge part of it comes down to social behavior.
Parrots are incredibly social animals. In the wild, they form really, really strong bonds with other parrots, often mating for life.
AC: Ah, another Disney movie moment.
SD: I know so much Disney. Theyâre also constantly communicating with their partner and flock.
AC: All right, so how do humans come in then?
SD: Well in captivity, these birds donât have a flock. Instead they have us, you know?
AC: Oh, so we become their flock?
SD: Right, When a parrot starts mimicking your voice, itâs not just about copying sounds for fun. Itâs about trying to connect with you. Itâs saying, âHey Annie, youâre my person now and Iâm going to learn your language.â
AC: Oh no. So my parrot was not trying to annoy me. It was trying to be my friend?
SD: Maybe.
AC: Alright, Iâm skeptical and now I feel a little bad. But I also want to know how are birds doing this? I imagine copying human speech is not easy.
SD: Yeah, this is where things get really cool. Birds that mimic human speech have a specialized part of their brains called the song system.
Itâs basically a neural network that helps them learn and produce complex sounds.
AC: So theyâre wired to learn different sounds?
SD: Exactly. And then thereâs the hardware. The thing actually making the sound,
AC: The beak?
SD: Not quite. Itâs an organ called the syrinx. Itâs basically their version of a voice box. The syrinx sits deep in their chest, and itâs actually way more efficient than our larynx.
AC: More efficient how?
SD: It allows birds to control airflow and vibrations in really, really precise ways so they can produce a huge range of soundsâeven sounds that donât exist in their natural repertoire, like human speech.
AC: So they have the brain and the instrument to say words.
SD: Exactly.
AC: Okay, but when a bird says something like âhello,â or âno,â or âshut up,â does it actually know what it means?
SD: Okay. This is where things get a little fuzzy. Birds are really good at forming associations, so they might learn that saying âhelloâ gets a reaction, or saying âcrackerâ gets them food.
AC: So theyâre connecting words to outcomes.
SD: Exactly. But that doesnât mean they necessarily understand language the way we do.
They donât know what âcrackerâ means. They just know what happens when they say it. At least thatâs what researchers can confirm at this point.
AC: So they might be able to understand more?
SD: Potentially. Take the example of Puck the Budgie. Puck learned an astounding 1,728 English words before passing away at the young age of five in 1994.
He even got a Guinness World Record for largest human vocabulary of any bird.
AC: Oh, yay. Go Puck!
SD: Right? And Puck could even form sentences. Researchers have also documented how birds can categorize things like colors or shapes. And in the wild, some birds use specific calls to communicate that say thereâs a threat nearby.
Like chickadees, they use varying numbers of âDâ notes in their calls to indicate possible threats. The more âDâ notes they use, the higher the risk. So maybe thereâs more going on than researchers currently understand.
AC: Okay. Iâm reluctant to say that birds are kind of brilliant, even if they scare me a little.
SD: They really are! And it gets even cooler. So maybe Iâll convince you to give them a second chance. Some birds in the wild even develop regional dialects.
AC: No way.
SD: Researchers have found the parrots in different places actually sound different, kind of like human accents. They also can develop calls that mean specific things in specific places.
AC: So birds have like their own slang versions of yinz and yâall.
SD: Yeah. Bird slang is absolutely real, and itâs learned, not genetic. Kind of like how people say sub versus hoagie.
AC: All right, I love that.
SD: Right. So to bring it all together, birds are wired to learn sounds, bond with others, and communicate. And when humans enter the picture, we become part of the flock.
AC: Aww. So when birds talk, itâs their way of bonding with the person theyâre closest to.Â
This is all incredibly wholesome, and I donât know if Iâm fully sold on parrots. But we do love to learn.
SD: We do. And also very fair. And with that, weâll be back with one final bird fact that honestly might change how you see parrots forever, Annie.
AC: Hmm. Skeptical.
SD: Okay. Well thatâs coming up after this quick break.
And weâre back! After all this talk about parrots mimicking humans, I have one last delightful update from the bird world.
AC: Alright, hit me.
SD: Researchers recently found evidence that some parrots may actually use names.
AC: Really?
SD: Yep. Namesâas in, like specific labels for specific individuals.
AC: All right, hold on.
So like, âHi Steve. Hello, Frank.â
SD: Kind of. Yeah, scientists looked at reports from hundreds of companion parrots and found that many birds seem to learn and use names properlyâfor humans, other pets, and sometimes other birds. Weâll link to the story on popsci.com in the show notes.
AC: I mean, I gotta hand it to âem that is impressive.
SD: Right? And it makes sense when you think about it. Parrots are super social animals. Humans use names to manage complicated social lives, and parrots also live in complex social groups.
AC: Yeah. So if you have a whole flock to keep track of, names are useful.
SD: Exactly. And parrots donât just use names the way we do.
AC: How so?
SD: Well, and I kind of love this, researchers found that some birds repeatedly say their own name to get attention.
AC: Oh.
SD: So did your childhood parrot Polly ever scream her own name?
AC: Come to think of it, she did. And she also spoke in the third person a lot, a little bit like Elmo. So she would say the classic âPolly want a cracker,â and I feel like she would just say her name to mimic, or I think as I thought as a child, mock us, now that Iâm thinking back on it.
SD: Ooh, very intense mockery. So to recap: Parrots can bond with you. They can mimic your voice, and they may even call you by your name.
AC: Okay. I hate to admit it, but I canât help but be impressed.
SD: Youâre coming around.
AC: Letâs not get carried away.Â
And thatâs it for this episode. But donât worry, we have more episodes of Ask Us Anything live in our feed right now.
Follow or subscribe to Ask Us Anything by Popular Science, wherever you enjoy your podcasts. And if you like our show, leave a rating and a review.
SD: Our producer is Alan Haburchak. This weekâs episode is based on articles written for Popular Science by Laura Kiniry and Margherita Bassi.
AC: Thank you team. Thank you birds. Not all birds. And thank you to everyone for listening.
SD: And one more time, if you want something youâve always wondered about explained on a future episode, go to popsci.com/ask and click the âAsk Usâ link. Until next time, keep the questions coming!Â
Bird: Thank you baby.
SD: Wait, Annie, before you go, you have to hear the most impressive parrots Iâve yet to share on the episode.
May I introduce the Rihannas of the bird world!
AC: You may!
Bird: Iâm friends with the monster thatâs under my bed. Get along with the voices inside of my head.
SD: Itâs like actually good.
AC: Itâs very good. Iâd listen to this on Spotify. Put this on Spotify.
I canât sing in human, so I also cannot sing in bird.
