The murder trial I can’t forget
Add Rob Rinder: the Crime I Can’t Forget to your watchlist There are some cases that follow you home. Not immediately. At first they exist only as paperwork, evidence and legal argument. You tell yourself you’ve done your job professionally. You move on. Another client. Another trial. But every so often, years later something returns uninvited: a face, a photograph, a fragment of testimony, a mother’s voice. For nearly 20 years that case for me has been the unsolved murder of Lucy Hargreaves. Lucy was 22 when she was shot dead in her home in Liverpool in 2005. Afterwards, the killers set fire to the house. Upstairs, her partner and small child escaped through a window. Even now, writing those words, I feel the same chill I felt when I first read the case papers as a young criminal defence barrister. The trial itself carried an atmosphere I have never forgotten. This was Liverpool at a moment of deep distrust between parts of the community and the police. Rumour travelled faster than evidence. Fear sat …









